
For Bush's final address to the American people, I was actually surprised that on the news and the commentary, it took a back seat to the "Miracle on the Hudson" that occurred earlier in the day when a USAirways jet filled with 150 passengers flew in the path of some migrating Canadian geese just minutes after taking off from LaGuardia. The experienced pilot treated the river like a runway and brought the plane down safely, and boats along the Hudson rushed over to rescue passengers in the freezing waters.
You know what this reminds me of? The movie
Donnie Darko. I can't help but see some kind of metaphor in this event happening on the day Bush was scheduled to give his final speech as (p)resident. According to director Richard Kelly (just a few years younger than I am), he envisioned a plane's engine falling out of the sky as being a metaphor for the end of the Reagan era. He set his movie in 1988, in the midst of the presidential election between Papa Bush and Dukakis. Though the movie lacks a coherent sense of logic, its the original premise that gets me. The film's plot rests on the airplane engine falling on Donnie Darko's bedroom. That the director views it somehow as the end of the Reagan years, what the heck does it mean? The cool thing about the film is that Donnie Darko makes the choice to go back in time to sacrifice his life to save that of his mother and sister (through some weird timeline), who were on the plane that lost an engine. If only Bush would volunteer to go back in time and give up the presidency to Gore in 2000 for the betterment of our country (and his own salvation).
The movie bombed in theaters because it had the unfortunate release date of October 2001, when no American wanted to see any dark movie, especially one featuring a crashing airplane (even though the film was looking for a distributor since the Sundance Film Festival earlier in the year). Had it been released in July or August, it might have done better in theaters (who knew 9/11 would happen, though?), but my guess is that the distributors didn't know how to market the movie and since it takes place around Halloween, they thought of it as a Halloween type of release. Wrong!

So, what would the metaphor be with the airline crash? Maybe the plane represents our country. It crashed during Bush's last week in office. It's sinking, but Americans safely bailed out and did so in an orderly fashion. Others came to their aid. It's America at its best (no selfishness there, no rich person demanding to be rescued first in a yacht, no situation like the Titanic where poor passengers were locked from escaping the sinking ship). When I see pictures of the plane sinking in water, I just keep thinking of Bush's failed presidency. He has been our pilot these past eight years. However, the plane was brought down by innocent birds that didn't get out of the flight path, not an incompetent pilot. But it does bring to mind a certain idea. Why do Americans want competent pilots and doctors? The answer is pretty obvious, right? It's in our self-interest. No rational person would board a plane if they knew the pilot was drunk off his ass or flying on his very first flight.
Yet, when it comes to politics, why doesn't competence matter as much? In 2000...in the Republican primary, voters had a choice between an experienced politician with a war hero record and a six-year governor who was the son of a former president. Then in the fall election, Americans had a choice between a man who had eight years experience as an understudy to the president and 24 years in government service overall, versus one who only got into politics six years earlier. Weird. Americans want competence when it comes to choosing a doctor or flying a plane, but when it comes to the most powerful job in the world with the greatest responsibilities, there are enough people who vote for the person they most want to drink a beer with. And last year, many millions of people supposedly voted for McCain because they loved Palin and thought she was "just like them!"
It's amazing that a plane crash got more attention than Bush's farewell address. Even his Vice President was caught dozing during parts of his speech! However, I want to dissect his speech because I was shocked that he brought up 9/11 one more time. I don't understand why a person would continue to highlight the biggest failure of his administration and almost brag about it. But that wasn't the only outrageous claim of his speech. I will highlight the points he made and refute them here.
Fellow citizens: For eight years, it has been my honor to serve as your President. The first decade of this new century has been a period of consequence -- a time set apart. Tonight, with a thankful heart, I have asked for a final opportunity to share some thoughts on the journey that we have traveled together, and the future of our nation.
"Has been a period of consequence"?!? I guess if you think of 9/11 as karmic payback for 50 years of American foreign policy of funding terrorist groups to undermine governments of other countries that don't agree with us...yeah. It has been a period of consequence. If you consider his reckless pursuit of terrorism as a military action rather than a police and intelligence services action, then yes, his period as leader of the free world will have huge consequences for decades.
Five days from now, the world will witness the vitality of American democracy. In a tradition dating back to our founding, the presidency will pass to a successor chosen by you, the American people. Standing on the steps of the Capitol will be a man whose history reflects the enduring promise of our land. This is a moment of hope and pride for our whole nation. And I join all Americans in offering best wishes to President-Elect Obama, his wife Michelle, and their two beautiful girls.
Wow, he was actually gracious here. More than he was towards Gore, the man who was chosen by the majority of the American people to lead our nation in the first decade of the new century and millennium.
Tonight I am filled with gratitude -- to Vice President Cheney and members of my administration; to Laura, who brought joy to this house and love to my life; to our wonderful daughters, Barbara and Jenna; to my parents, whose examples have provided strength for a lifetime. And above all, I thank the American people for the trust you have given me. I thank you for the prayers that have lifted my spirits. And I thank you for the countless acts of courage, generosity, and grace that I have witnessed these past eight years.
I never gave any trust to you because you didn't deserve any. And the only prayers that I prayed on your behalf is that the American people would wake up to your lies and that you'll be held accountable for your crimes against the country and world. If Americans are courageous, generous, and graceful, it was in defiance of you and your policy of encouraging fear, greed, and political pettiness.
This evening, my thoughts return to the first night I addressed you from this house -- September the 11th, 2001. That morning, terrorists took nearly 3,000 lives in the worst attack on America since Pearl Harbor. I remember standing in the rubble of the World Trade Center three days later, surrounded by rescuers who had been working around the clock. I remember talking to brave souls who charged through smoke-filled corridors at the Pentagon, and to husbands and wives whose loved ones became heroes aboard Flight 93. I remember Arlene Howard, who gave me her fallen son's police shield as a reminder of all that was lost. And I still carry his badge.
I can't believe that you brought up your biggest failure as president one last time. What is with your obsession with 9/11? Clinton never talked ad nauseum about the Oklahoma City bombing, or the Branch Davidian Complex disaster in Waco, or even the 1993 bombing of the World Trade Center each time he gave a speech. What kind of twisted person wants to remind everyone of his biggest failure? Maybe a person who has little accomplishments to speak of because he's deluded in thinking that 9/11 was his finest hour.
As the years passed, most Americans were able to return to life much as it had been before 9/11. But I never did. Every morning, I received a briefing on the threats to our nation. I vowed to do everything in my power to keep us safe.
So, why didn't you do that on day one of your presidency? Why did you ignore the CIA's PDB on August 6th? Why did you ignore the departing Clinton Administration's insistence that terrorism would be your biggest focus? Why did you marginalize Richard Clarke everytime he had something important to say about al-Qaeda? Why did you sit in that classroom for 7 minutes after being told we were under attack? Why did it take you three days to appear in public after 9/11?
Over the past seven years, a new Department of Homeland Security has been created. The military, the intelligence community, and the FBI have been transformed. Our nation is equipped with new tools to monitor the terrorists' movements, freeze their finances, and break up their plots. And with strong allies at our side, we have taken the fight to the terrorists and those who support them. Afghanistan has gone from a nation where the Taliban harbored al Qaeda and stoned women in the streets to a young democracy that is fighting terror and encouraging girls to go to school. Iraq has gone from a brutal dictatorship and a sworn enemy of America to an Arab democracy at the heart of the Middle East and a friend of the United States.
Iraq an Arab democracy and friend of the United States? Then why are many government officials in the post-Saddam Iraq closely tied to the Iranian government?
There is legitimate debate about many of these decisions. But there can be little debate about the results. America has gone more than seven years without another terrorist attack on our soil. This is a tribute to those who toil night and day to keep us safe -- law enforcement officers, intelligence analysts, homeland security and diplomatic personnel, and the men and women of the United States Armed Forces.
Little debate about the results? America's more hated abroad than when you took office eight years ago. America went without a terrorist attack eight years BEFORE 9/11. Some time ago, the media revealed that terrorists had planned several attacks in the U.S. for the Millennium New Year's celebrations in Seattle, Los Angeles, and Washington, D.C. Seems like the Clinton Administration did a good job thwarting such attacks. It's what a president is expected to do. Claiming that no attack happened on your watch is like claiming that no aliens invaded our country during your presidency. You can claim all kinds of things that never happened as a sign of "doing your job."
Our nation is blessed to have citizens who volunteer to defend us in this time of danger. I have cherished meeting these selfless patriots and their families. And America owes you a debt of gratitude. And to all our men and women in uniform listening tonight: There has been no higher honor than serving as your Commander-in-Chief.
For a coward who avoided war as a young man--a war you believed in--you ought to feel small and humbled by the young Americans you committed to the slaughterhouse of Iraq. Your debt to them for fighting an illegal war you ordered is truly astronomical and I hope you will donate your wealth to all those who are suffering from their injuries.
The battles waged by our troops are part of a broader struggle between two dramatically different systems. Under one, a small band of fanatics demands total obedience to an oppressive ideology, condemns women to subservience, and marks unbelievers for murder. The other system is based on the conviction that freedom is the universal gift of Almighty God, and that liberty and justice light the path to peace.
When you said "a small band of fanatics demands total obedience to an oppressive ideology," I actually laughed because I thought you were finally admitting what your administration truly is. Maybe that's the case...your administration on one hand, the American people on the other hand. I'm glad that I never joined your side these past eight years. It was great to oppose you and your illegitimate presidency for eight years.
This is the belief that gave birth to our nation. And in the long run, advancing this belief is the only practical way to protect our citizens. When people live in freedom, they do not willingly choose leaders who pursue campaigns of terror. When people have hope in the future, they will not cede their lives to violence and extremism. So around the world, America is promoting human liberty, human rights, and human dignity. We're standing with dissidents and young democracies, providing AIDS medicine to dying patients -- to bring dying patients back to life, and sparing mothers and babies from malaria. And this great republic born alone in liberty is leading the world toward a new age when freedom belongs to all nations.
I was struck by your phrase: "when people live in freedom, they do not willingly choose leaders who pursue campaigns of terror." You got that right! The majority of Americans did not choose you to lead us in the new century, but you waged your campaigns of terror anyway.
You're standing with dissidents? You don't even like dissidents in this country. You had protestors limited to "free speech zones" out of your eyesight, you wouldn't allow anyone who wasn't a card-carrying member of the Republican party to attend your campaign events in 2004, you tried to blacklist people who disagreed with you and your policies.
For eight years, we've also strived to expand opportunity and hope here at home. Across our country, students are rising to meet higher standards in public schools. A new Medicare prescription drug benefit is bringing peace of mind to seniors and the disabled. Every taxpayer pays lower income taxes. The addicted and suffering are finding new hope through faith-based programs. Vulnerable human life is better protected. Funding for our veterans has nearly doubled. America's air and water and lands are measurably cleaner. And the federal bench includes wise new members like Justice Sam Alito and Chief Justice John Roberts.
If Americans pay less in income taxes, we pay more in other fees, taxes, and cost of living...even as salaries have stagnated. Honestly, I was better off financially in the Clinton years.
Funding for veterans was more the doing of the Democratic Congress than you. Faith-based programs have a tendency to place conditions on those they helped (such as: after you listen to our message about Jesus, we will happily help you). Having big corporations re-write our laws for air quality, water, and land is hardly making these resources cleaner. And appointing regressive ideologues to the Supreme Court is hardly a sign that they are at all wise.
When challenges to our prosperity emerged, we rose to meet them. Facing the prospect of a financial collapse, we took decisive measures to safeguard our economy. These are very tough times for hardworking families, but the toll would be far worse if we had not acted. All Americans are in this together. And together, with determination and hard work, we will restore our economy to the path of growth. We will show the world once again the resilience of America's free enterprise system.
All Americans are not in this together. Why do the CEOs get a golden parachute and not have to pay for their crimes of greed and incompetence? Where's my bailout? I'm saddled with college loan debt, stuck in a job that pays the same salary I made when I didn't have a degree or college loan debt. I've searched for a better paying job throughout your term in office and all I've found are low wage jobs that don't pay shit. The times are tough for hardworking families because you acted to benefit your rich supporters in the biggest kleptocratic looting our nation has ever seen. And your buddies who did this aren't going to pay for it either.
Like all who have held this office before me, I have experienced setbacks. There are things I would do differently if given the chance. Yet I've always acted with the best interests of our country in mind. I have followed my conscience and done what I thought was right. You may not agree with some of the tough decisions I have made. But I hope you can agree that I was willing to make the tough decisions.
Most of the setbacks you experienced were actually karmic payback because you were dishonest when you came into office and proceeded to act in a greedy and dishonest manner. Of course everything would come crashing down. I'm glad it happened before you left office, so Americans could see the fraud that you are.
You've never acted with the best interests of the country in mind. You were a corporate whore who did what you had to do for your criminal class of wealthy elites. I don't believe you have a conscience at all, and you have proved it with every interview you gave these past few months where you can't think of any major mistakes or offer any apology for those you mistreated along the way. Yes, I don't agree with your "tough decisions" because what you lacked was making wise decisions. It's not easy to be president, I'm not refuting you there. Most decisions are tough decisions...but when your decisions favour deceit over honesty, the wealthy over the poor and middle class, violence instead of diplomacy, ideology instead of pragmatism...you were incapable of making any decision that went against the narrow ideology of neo-conservativism.
The decades ahead will bring more hard choices for our country, and there are some guiding principles that should shape our course. While our nation is safer than it was seven years ago, the gravest threat to our people remains another terrorist attack. Our enemies are patient, and determined to strike again. America did nothing to seek or deserve this conflict. But we have been given solemn responsibilities, and we must meet them. We must resist complacency. We must keep our resolve. And we must never let down our guard.
You lied here when you said that "America did nothing to seek or deserve this conflict." Come on, Mr. History Major. Surely you had to have learned that our foreign policy of supporting terrorist groups during the Cold War to undermine the Soviet Empire has resulted in what the CIA termed "blowback." Many of the people we funded over the years (Noriega, Osama Bin Laden, Saddam Hussein) had turned against us. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Jesus (your favourite political philosopher) even preached this principle. Your war on terrorism in which you have arrested and tortured possible innocent people will only turn them into terrorists with vengeance on their minds.
Your whole presidency has been complacent, particularly in the months leading up to 9/11.
At the same time, we must continue to engage the world with confidence and clear purpose. In the face of threats from abroad, it can be tempting to seek comfort by turning inward. But we must reject isolationism and its companion, protectionism. Retreating behind our borders would only invite danger. In the 21st century, security and prosperity at home depend on the expansion of liberty abroad. If America does not lead the cause of freedom, that cause will not be led.
I hope this was a message to the isolationist wing of your party. This is the only part of your speech that I agree with. But I can't help but think of the contrast it had from your view as expressed in the 2000 debates when you criticized the Clinton Administration for its "nation-building" activities, and you vowed a "more humble" foreign policy. Why is an international cooperative effort to end genocide or massacres wrong, but pre-emptively invading oil rich countries just?
As we address these challenges -- and others we cannot foresee tonight -- America must maintain our moral clarity. I've often spoken to you about good and evil, and this has made some uncomfortable. But good and evil are present in this world, and between the two of them there can be no compromise. Murdering the innocent to advance an ideology is wrong every time, everywhere. Freeing people from oppression and despair is eternally right. This nation must continue to speak out for justice and truth. We must always be willing to act in their defense -- and to advance the cause of peace.
The reason why "good and evil" makes me uncomfortable is because you have a simple-minded and immature view of it. Don't you realize that when Osama Bin Laden looks in the mirror, he doesn't see an evil man looking back at him? He views you as evil. He views our foreign policy as evil. I believe the world is more complex than mere good and evil. To me, evil is characterized by dishonesty, greed, cruelty, the love of violence. In my mind, your administration is EVIL. You said it yourself: "murdering the innocent to advance an ideology is wrong every time, every where." How many innocent Iraqi and Pashtun blood are on your hands? You've been advancing your own warped ideology, regardless of the consequences and your thirst for control of oil is nothing, if not greedy and evil. Evil because you have shown time and again, that a material item is worth more than a human life.
If freeing people from oppression and despair is always eternally right, then why have you done nothing about Darfur or Burma? Why is your liberation based on countries that have oil or important geography for an oil pipeline?
President Thomas Jefferson once wrote, "I like the dreams of the future better than the history of the past." As I leave the house he occupied two centuries ago, I share that optimism. America is a young country, full of vitality, constantly growing and renewing itself. And even in the toughest times, we lift our eyes to the broad horizon ahead.
How dare you quote Jefferson! You have no stature at all and you don't know the first thing about Jefferson. The quote is convenient though. Of course you want Americans to focus on the future and to forgive the crimes of your presidency. Anyone who robs another person would want the victim to forgive and forget. They don't want to be held accountable for their past. Its the flaw of Christianity. That's why the law of karmic justice takes care of that. You can't escape your past. Every action has consequences.
I have confidence in the promise of America because I know the character of our people. This is a nation that inspires immigrants to risk everything for the dream of freedom. This is a nation where citizens show calm in times of danger, and compassion in the face of suffering. We see examples of America's character all around us. And Laura and I have invited some of them to join us in the White House this evening...
...In citizens like these, we see the best of our country - resilient and hopeful, caring and strong. These virtues give me an unshakable faith in America. We have faced danger and trial, and there's more ahead. But with the courage of our people and confidence in our ideals, this great nation will never tire, never falter, and never fail.
Shameless, how you continue to highlight the very people who were victimized by your incompetence. Yes, these people might be the best of our country but you have no moral standing to even be compared with any of them. They are courageous where you cower in your fears. America is great in spite of you and everything you stand for.
It has been the privilege of a lifetime to serve as your President. There have been good days and tough days. But every day I have been inspired by the greatness of our country, and uplifted by the goodness of our people. I have been blessed to represent this nation we love. And I will always be honored to carry a title that means more to me than any other - citizen of the United States of America. And so, my fellow Americans, for the final time: Good night. May God bless this house and our next President. And may God bless you and our wonderful country. Thank you.
You might have been "blessed" but you screwed us royally. You squandered a privilege of a lifetime and dishonored the office that many honorable men have occupied with grace, courage, ethics and moral clarity. You are the worst person to ever hold that office and I thank God everyday that your disasterous presidency is finished. America can now be great again as we reverse and clean up your damaging presidency. I hope you disappear into obscurity, never to be heard from again unless its to face a war crimes tribunal or that you have died. Good riddance. And I hope the door does hit you on the way out.